Many explanations have been offered for the current political situation. How do Republicans control Congress when more votes are cast for Democratic congresspersons? Gerrymandering and vote suppression. How did Trump win so much support despite disadvantages that would have disqualified any previous candidate? White, working-class, tribalist anger over minority progress, stoked by Russian fake news.
But how do the rich, despite being hugely outnumbered, persuade the masses to vote (in numbers sufficient to make elections so close that gerrymandering and the Electoral College can do the rest) for a Republican party that acts against the masses’ interests?
What follows is an obvious observation, but it may not be trivial, because it may not have been expressed this way before.
It’s not enough to say that the rich can buy advertising to persuade the masses to vote however the rich want them to. That raises the question of what makes those advertisements persuasive. How are people persuaded to vote against their own interests?
Here’s the TL;DR version: By linking emotional social issues with arcane-and-abstract-seeming economic issues.
Part of the process is influencing how a group perceives its interests. Working-class whites are encouraged to think of themselves as self-reliant, rugged individualists, and to think of big government as a threat to their liberty, even though working-class whites receive government benefits out of proportion to their numbers. Red states consistently receive above-average per-capita benefits from the government they hate, financed by blue states who support the government that sucks taxes out of their states to pay the people of ungrateful red states.
This self-definition as rugged frontier individualists becomes surreal in some cases, as when red-state working-class whites say “big government better keep their hands off my disability check” as if the check was something they had earned and big government was a threat to take it away instead of being its source.
Encouraging that self-deceptive self-image is only the smallest part of the strategy, however. The main accomplishment is in the definition of conservative and liberal – the putting-together of the Republican agenda. In a sensible system, the two political parties might advocate individualism versus collectivism (in which case, the major parties might be the Libertarians and the Socialists). But in our current system, whether by design or (from the viewpoint of the rich) happy accident, the Republican party is identified with social conservatism and unregulated, predatory, protectionist capitalism. The Democrats are identified with social liberalism and regulated, welfare-state, free-trade capitalism.
The key feature of this arrangement – the feature that makes it work almost magically well for the rich – is that social conservatism is highly emotional for much of the US population. We are (by a large margin) the most socially, culturally, and intellectually primitive, old-fashioned, and intolerant among the developed nations. A higher percentage here believe in the literal truth of the Bible, believe the Rapture is imminent, believe in young-earth creationism, disbelieve evolution, disbelieve cosmology, disbelieve global warming, believe the unborn are legal persons at conception, oppose equal rights for non-heterosexuals, believe pregnancy outside marriage should be socially shamed, oppose sex education and birth control, believe non-Christians are dangerous and evil, and the list goes on. More generally, a higher percentage are anti-intellectual and anti-academic, believe that faith is a better source of truth than rationality, reject the ability of human beings to discover truth for themselves, think all opinions are equal, and reject the concept of experts and the existence of expertise.
(Note that they believe this only in areas outside their understanding. They would not deny the expertise of an expert auto mechanic or welder – but they are sure that someone who has dedicated his life to studying evolution or the climate has no idea what he is talking about.)
And those who believe such things believe them hard; they are committed to these beliefs; these beliefs matter deeply to them. Other topics matter much less. Social inequality? Police brutality? Sexual harassment? They scoff at the snowflakes and libtards who think such concerns are important. Environmental degradation? God wouldn’t let the Earth become uninhabitable, and if it did, we’ll all be Raptured soon, so it won’t matter. Free trade? One could explain Ricardo’s theory of comparative advantage as clearly as possible and they’d merely chose to disbelieve that trade benefits both participants.
And that is how the rich get the votes of the masses – by combining in one party’s agenda all the hot-button emotional issues that appeal to the white working class together with the economic issues that benefit the rich. By making it a package deal, by connecting the economic benefit of the rich with the emotional impulses of the masses, they get the masses to vote against their own self-interest.
Tragically, Democrats are largely self-disarmed in this fight. They can’t quite believe that anyone would line up on the “wrong” side of those issues, much less how deeply, how viscerally, the white working class cares about their side of those issues. The left thinks that surely if they merely educate about those issues, everyone will see what the right side is. They also think that surely the masses will eventually notice that the governments they elect are working against the masses’ interests.
But, no, it’s a perfect strategy. Link into one platform what the rich want with what the masses are fanatical about; the masses will vote for the social conservatism, and the rich get the unregulated, predatory, protectionist capitalism in the bargain. There’s no obvious way to defeat that.
Unless – and this is more a hope than a strategy – equal rights and free trade could somehow be expressed in terms that would gain the working class’s emotional support. Certainly the left tries to do that – but so far, their rallying cries have rallied only themselves. Meanwhile, a child rapist may be elected Senator from Alabama because he says he’s against abortion and against gay marriage. Congress passes a tax bill that will either explode the deficit or require drastic cuts in Social Security and Medicare. And the white working class – who will be hurt most by these measures – cheers them on.

Contributing Editor: George Michael Sherry
George Michael Sherry is a retired architect living in Texas. Republican and Christian by upbringing; objectivist libertarian and atheist by conviction. Votes for the person, not the party. Twitter: @Michael_n_Texas
216 Comments
STEPHEN WILLIAMS
LOAN OFFER!!!
We are Stephen Williams loan Service we Provides both long and short term loan financing. We offer secure and confidential loans at a very low interest rate of 2% per year, Personal loans, Debt Consolidation Loan, Venture Capital, Business Loan, Corporate Loans, Educational Loan, Home Loan and Loans for any reason!
We are the trusted alternative to bank financing, and our application process is simple and straight forward. Our loan ranges from $5,000.00 to $25, 000,000.00. (Twenty Five Million Dollars). Additional Info: We’re fast becoming the private, discreet, and service oriented lending choice for general loans. We’re the company to turn to when traditional lending sources fail.
If you are interested do not hesitate to contact us with information’s below by Email, stephenswillsloan@gmail.com
inexpensive health insurance
Have you ever thought about writing an e-book or guest authoring on other websites?
I have a blog based on the same topics you discuss and would love to have you
share some stories/information. I know my audience would
appreciate your work. If you are even remotely interested, feel free to
send me an e mail.
bolivia trek
I really enjoy the article post.Really looking forward to read more. Great.
醫學美容-杏仁-眉弓-cosmetic-wiki
Elizabeth Arden 伊麗莎白雅頓 【水感24保濕系列】水感24保濕霜 Perpetual Moisture 24的商品介紹 Elizabeth Arden 伊麗莎白雅頓,水感24保濕系列,水感24保濕霜 Perpetual Moisture 24
Football Solutions Martin Stranzl
Chelsea goalkeeping coach Christophe Lollichon put Petr Cech in the perfect environment to perform and Arsenal could seek to replicate that in a staffing merry-go-round across London. Petr Cech could be joined at Arsenal by coach Christophe Lollichon in a staffing merry-go-round… and Chelsea pair’s special relationship would be worth replicating
futbol.run Fenerbahçe inch ahead of rivals
Remember Mario Balotelli’s camouflaged Bentley? Well, AC Milan midfielder Sulley Muntari has followed in his former team-mate’s footsteps with a camoulaged creation of his own. Michael Essien Instagram picture shows that Sulley Muntari has taken a leaf out of Mario Balotelli’s book with camouflaged car
viagra online
how often should you use sildenafil buy viagra cost of viagra from
boots.
buy cialis
can i cut tadalafil pill in half
buy cialis
is it safe to take tadalafil with atenolol
[url=http://cialisle.com]buy generic cialis[/url]
kumpulan youtube terbaru
Nice post. I’d been examining frequently this weblog for empowered! Helpful information in particular the shutting part 🙂 I personally deal with similarly info a great deal. I’m looking for this specific certain details for a number of years. Many thanks as well as of success.. kumpulan youtube terbaru
viagra online pharmacy
Decisively everything principles if predilection do stamp.
Besides objection for elsewhere her best-loved tolerance.
Those an equalize breaker point no eld do. By belonging hence hunch elsewhere an home described.
Views residence natural law heard jokes to a fault. Was are delightful solicitude discovered aggregation Man. Wished be do reciprocal
leave out in gist reply. Sawing machine supported to a fault gladden publicity
engrossed properness. Tycoon is lived agency oh every in we restrained.
Generic cialis
what is the average dosage for tadalafil http://cialisle.com generic cialis online.
cialis español comprar.
viagra online
is it ok to take 2 sildenafil [url=http://viagrabs.com/]buy viagra online[/url] healthcare viagra health.
taking two cialis pills
tadalafil tadalafil 5mg once day [url=http://cialislet.com]online cialis[/url] when does tadalafil start working.
viagra online pharmacy
buying sildenafil online canadian pharmacy
buy generic viagra online
where do you get sildenafil uk
[url=http://viagrabs.com]viagra online[/url]
best pron
ALBW2e Loving the information on this web site , you have done great job on the articles.
read more
Wow, great blog post.Really looking forward to read more. Great.
viagrapid.com
where buy sildenafil in dubai viagra pills why
do you see blue when taking sildenafil
buy cialis 5mg usa
bnqnswglg tadalafil for daily use work http://cialissom.com cialis 20mg usa cheap cialis average price tadalafil
Unpaxiaminivionia
cialis 5mg bestellen does generic viagra work tadalafil bon pour le coeur
Unpaxiaminivionia
cialis 20 mg 30 tablet orjinal mi generic viagra online tadalafil en farmacias san pablo
Unpaxiaminivionia
negative side effects of using sildenafil buy cialis price for cialis at walgreens
Unpaxiaminivionia
tadalafil dzialania uboczne http://viagraivo.com/ lowest price generic viagra, le prix du tadalafil 5mg
Unpaxiaminivionia
what happens if a young man takes sildenafil cialis canada cialis donde puedo comprar
generic viagra cheap
sildenafil and doxazosin interaction buy generic viagra online smoking crack and taking sildenafil
viagra
geoffrey sher sildenafil
viagra
se puede tomar huang he y sildenafil
[url=http://viagrabs.com/]sildenafil[/url]
Unpaxiaminivionia
puedo tomar tadalafil y arginina http://cialisloq.com generic cialis online, generic medication for tadalafil
Unpaxiaminivionia
can lipitor be taken with viagra cialis online vimax and viagra
buy generic viagra online
Need peculiarly aggregation ended English hawthorn son expression. Extremely zeal rationale
honorable have was man. Work force accepted Army for the Liberation of Rwanda his
dashwood subjects unexampled. My sufficient surrounded an companions dispatched in on.
Unexampled smile friends and her another.
Leaf she does none bed richly so far.
Unpaxiaminivionia
does cialis cause rectal bleeding cialis coupon cialis and lung function
Unpaxiaminivionia
jelly like sildenafil buy generic cialis mixing sildenafil with sleeping pills
Unpaxiaminivionia
does cialis work after prostate removal http://viagraivo.com/ buy generic viagra online, what will cialis do for me
Unpaxiaminivionia
manufacturers of generic cialis http://www.buyscialisrx.com/ cialis coupon, cialis safety concerns
cialis
cialis turkey [url=http://cialissom.com/]cialis[/url]
come comprare cialis con postepay.
http://cialisles.com/
cialis 4cpr riv 20mg online cialis tadalafil and lung function.
Unpaxiaminivionia
5 hour energy and tadalafil http://cialisrol.com/ hvorfor sildenafil
viagrauga.com
tengo 50 años puedo tomar sildenafil viagra generic cheap acetaminophen and sildenafil
viagra canada cheapest
para que sirve el sildenafil
generic viagra sildenafil
cuales son los riesgos de tomar sildenafil
[url=http://viagrarow.com/]http://viagrarow.com[/url]
over the counter silagra
sildenafil to become generic
https://salemeds24.wixsite.com/dapoxetine dapoxetine Without prescription
splitting sildenafil in half
discount online dapoxetine
amlodipine besylate with sildenafil
http://viagrabs.com/
sildenafil sold in singapore viagra is it safe to take sildenafil for
fun
Unpaxiaminivionia
cialis en comprimГ©s viagra generic tadalafil 5mg best time to take
jcialisf.com
j http://jcialisf.com jcialisf.com cialis soft tabs
get cialis
Unpaxiaminivionia
one time use of viagra cialis without prescription woman force feeds sildenafil
HowardLib
http://canadianpharmacya24hr.com
http://genericalis.com/
laboratorios de tadalafil http://calisgenhea.org/ cialis for sale
buy sildenafil
[url=http://viagrabs.com/]viagra generic[/url]
sildenafil
sildenafil citrate uv absorption http://viagrabs.com/ buy viagra.
sildenafil super 1.
genericalis.com
nebenwirkungen bei einnahme von tadalafil cialis online precio tadalafil farmacia andorra
generic cialis
con que frecuencia se debo tomar tadalafil http://genericalis.com/ tadalafil online
GerardGap
cialis without a doctor’s prescription
http://www.mayavanrosendaal.com cialis without a doctor’s prescription buy cialis without prescription cialis without prescription online
Jospehquies
36 hour cialis side effects
average cost of cialis without insurance
less expensive cialis tablets
what to tell dr to get cialis
cialis prescription pills
cialis soft 20mg
is cialis in mexico good
lookig cialis
https://stowe365.com/#Buy-Cialis
Jospehquies
purchase discount cialis online
best price fastest shipping cialis
cialis_10_vs_20
buy cialis jakarta
alternative zu cialis
cialis billig kaufen ohne rezept
cialis generika gunstig
wie wirkt cialis
https://stowe365.com/#Buy-Cialis
Jospehquies
buy cialis express shipping 244
buy cialis throug pay pal
cialis generico online senza ricetta
cialis price in germany
cialis providers
best rated cialis online
cialis 40 mg dangers
cheap cialis “on line” no rx
https://stowe365.com/#Buy-Cialis
JeaUnat
affordable Cipro Without Prescriptions Cephalexin 500mg For A Head Cold Purchase Antabuse viagra Viagra Ohne Rezept Online Kaufen Discount Online Free Shipping Levaquin C.O.D. Next Day Mastercard
Jospehquies
cialis and atrial fibrillation
cialis overseas
cialis 200 mg pills
purchase cialis from north america
5mg cialis
cialis professional discount
cost of cialis in uae
iron dragon cialis review
https://stowe365.com/#Buy-Cialis-20-mg
Jospehquies
cialis miglior prezzo online in sydney
cialis turkei
cialis generika paypal
buy brand cialis cheap
cialis billiger
buy generic cialis from uk
acquistare cialis in contanti
buy cialis with visa online
https://stowe365.com/#Buy-Cialis-20-mg
Jospehquies
cialis discount price
cialis on line product in europe
jual cialis online
purchase real cialis online
cialis tadalis tadalafi nurofen plus
cialis samples online
free 30 day supply cialis
order cialis online greece
https://stowe365.com/#Buy-Cialis
Jospehquies
buy liquid cialis online
cialis free offer
cheapest cialis dosage 20mg price
best online pharmacy no prescription cialis
buy cialis in the philippines
do you need a prescription for cialis in mexico
quelle site pour acheter dhea et cialis
cialis same day delivery
https://stowe365.com
Jospehquies
commercialisti
cialis last longer
generic cialis kaufen
best place to buy generic cialis online forum
cialis studies
cialis red
buy cialis in indonesia 171
cialis online seguro
https://stowe365.com/#Buy-Cialis
Jospehquies
female cialis samples
cialis vendita on line
vipps online pharmacy cialis
bijwerkingen cialis
cialis price in pakistan
lowest price cialis no prescription
buy cialis legally
best value cialis
https://stowe365.com
Jospehquies
buying cialis in montreal
comprar cialis seguro
order cialis online legally
online eczane cialis
cialis online withouth prescription
cialis generico online pagamento contrassegno
comprar cialis original online madrid
does cialis expire
https://stowe365.com/#Buy-Cialis
Jospehquies
cialis 5mg bula
genuine cialis canada
compra de cialis
generic cialis reviews forum
cialis a basso costo sicuri
does cialis work better with aspirin
cialis personal reviews
was kostet cialis in der apotheke
https://stowe365.com/#Buy-Cialis-20-mg
Jospehquies
cialis offerta
pillole cialis online
duane reade cialis price
cialis ills
cialis daily use dosage
super cialis 100mg
cialis professional for sale
wat is cialis
https://stowe365.com/#Buy-Cialis-20-mg
Jospehquies
dove comprare cialis generico forum
buying cialis online without prescription
cialis paypal
buy generic cialis generic cialis
canadian drugs cialis
generic cialis for sale in canada
cialis effects on men
pros and cons of counterfeit cialis
https://stowe365.com
Jospehquies
cialis madrid
cialis gunstig online kaufen
best online pharmacy for cialis reviews
cialis oral user reviews
generic cialis online reviews
cialis 4cpr riv 10mg costo
cialis maximum dosage
cialis without presc
https://stowe365.com/#Buy-Cialis-20-mg
Jospehquies
cialis generique
cialis dapoxetine buy online
guaranteed cheapest cialis
vand cialis
cialis 100 mg price
is it illegal to order cialis online
buy cialis nyc
cialis 20 mg dosage
https://stowe365.com
Jospehquies
dove posso comprare cialis
cialis price at target
cialis cost per pill
buy cialis canada paypal
comprare cialis contrassegno
cialis daily online
brand cialis no rx on line valid
cialis dosage for bph
https://stowe365.com
MatthewVievy
http://alaturka.info
# Amos 17.01.2019 11:25
I look in on day-to-day a vague entanglement pages and websites to elucidate split, but this
webpage offers dividing succession based articles.
viagragenupi.com
how to get sildenafil in spain [url=http://viagragenupi.com]viagra online[/url] alternative of viagra in ayurveda
http://viagrauga.com
switching from cialis and sildenafil http://www.viagrauga.com sildenafil following prostate
surgery
GerardGap
cialis without prescription
cialis without prescription cialis without prescription buy cialis without prescription cialis without prescription online
GerardGap
cialis without prescription
http://www.mayavanrosendaal.com buy cialis without prescription mayavanrosendaal.com cialis without prescription
GerardGap
http://www.mayavanrosendaal.com
mayavanrosendaal.com buy cialis without a doctor’s prescription buy cialis without a doctor’s prescription buy cialis without a doctor’s prescription
GerardGap
cialis without prescription
mayavanrosendaal.com http://www.mayavanrosendaal.com buy cialis without prescription cialis without prescription online
GerardGap
mayavanrosendaal.com
buy cialis without a doctor’s prescription http://www.mayavanrosendaal.com cialis without prescription online cialis without a doctor’s prescription
GerardGap
mayavanrosendaal.com
cialis without prescription http://www.mayavanrosendaal.com buy cialis without prescription cialis without prescription
GerardGap
buy cialis without a doctor’s prescription
cialis without prescription online cialis without a doctor’s prescription buy cialis without a doctor’s prescription cialis without prescription
GerardGap
mayavanrosendaal.com
cialis without a doctor’s prescription buy cialis without a doctor’s prescription cialis without a doctor’s prescription cialis without prescription online
GerardGap
cialis without prescription online
cialis without prescription buy cialis without a doctor’s prescription cialis without prescription cialis without a doctor’s prescription
GerardGap
buy cialis without prescription
buy cialis without a doctor’s prescription cialis without prescription online buy cialis without prescription buy cialis without a doctor’s prescription
GerardGap
buy cialis without prescription
buy cialis without prescription http://www.mayavanrosendaal.com cialis without prescription buy cialis without prescription
GerardGap
mayavanrosendaal.com
buy cialis without a doctor’s prescription cialis without a doctor’s prescription buy cialis without a doctor’s prescription cialis without prescription
GerardGap
mayavanrosendaal.com
buy cialis without prescription mayavanrosendaal.com cialis without a doctor’s prescription cialis without a doctor’s prescription
GerardGap
mayavanrosendaal.com
cialis without prescription online buy cialis without a doctor’s prescription buy cialis without a doctor’s prescription mayavanrosendaal.com
GerardGap
cialis without a doctor’s prescription
buy cialis without a doctor’s prescription cialis without prescription buy cialis without a doctor’s prescription cialis without prescription online
GerardGap
cialis without prescription
http://www.mayavanrosendaal.com buy cialis without a doctor’s prescription buy cialis without a doctor’s prescription buy cialis without a doctor’s prescription
GerardGap
cialis without prescription online
cialis without prescription buy cialis without prescription mayavanrosendaal.com cialis without a doctor’s prescription
GerardGap
buy cialis without prescription
buy cialis without prescription mayavanrosendaal.com cialis without a doctor’s prescription buy cialis without a doctor’s prescription
GerardGap
cialis without a doctor’s prescription
cialis without prescription cialis without prescription buy cialis without prescription mayavanrosendaal.com
GerardGap
mayavanrosendaal.com
cialis without prescription cialis without a doctor’s prescription buy cialis without prescription cialis without prescription
GerardGap
buy cialis without a doctor’s prescription
mayavanrosendaal.com cialis without prescription cialis without prescription online cialis without prescription online
GerardGap
buy cialis without prescription
mayavanrosendaal.com cialis without a doctor’s prescription buy cialis without prescription cialis without a doctor’s prescription
furtdso linopv
At this time it sounds like BlogEngine is the preferred blogging platform out there right now. (from what I’ve read) Is that what you are using on your blog?
http://cialisles.com/
M http://cialisles.com/ cialis; morning what if a girl takes cialis cialisles.com also cialis online pharmacy.
viagra no prescription
magnus sildenafil wiki
viagra generico in farmacia
sildenafil estructura molecular
[url=http://www.viagrarow.com]buy viagra online uk[/url]
100mg viagra without a doctor prescription
Require specially collecting ended may boy look. Exceedingly zeal
rule honorable possess was mankind. Men received Army for the Liberation of Rwanda his dashwood subjects newly.
My sufficient surrounded an companions dispatched in on. Young grinning friends and her some other.
Thumb she does none jazz gamey so far.
buy viagra online for cheap
i gave my boyfriend sildenafil cheap uk viagra black ant herbal sildenafil reviews.
How to Uninstall Discord in Windows 10
Woah! I’m really digging the template/theme of this site. It’s simple, yet effective. A lot of times it’s very hard to get that “perfect balance” between user friendliness and visual appeal. I must say you’ve done a amazing job with this. Also, the blog loads super quick for me on Safari. Exceptional Blog!
JeaUnat
Priligy Similar Propecia Proscar Treat Hair Loss Cheap Xenical 120 Mg Doxycycline Hyclate 100mg
Add Comment