Donald Trump’s Useless Eaters: #FreeRosa in the era of ascendant Fascism

In 1933, Adolf Hitler became Chancellor of Germany. In the same year, his National Socialist (Nazi) Party began a systematic campaign of public ridicule and private sterilization, isolation and murder of the disabled in Germany. When the Nazis were not stopped from claiming these first of their victims, the most vulnerable population among their citizens, the way was paved for the atrocities yet to come.

Called Lebensunwertes Leben (life unworthy of life) and nutzlose Esser (useless eaters) mentally and physically disabled, along with the chronically ill and those with non-disabling birth anomalies, were singled out as a burden on society. It began with the “Law for the Prevention of Progeny with Hereditary Diseases” mass sterilization. While it soon devolved to euthanasia, it started with the idea that “we cannot afford these burdens on our society.” The law made them “illegals.”

Sound familiar?

Many of you are probably scoffing, saying “That could never happen here.”

You’re wrong.

Consider this: in the early 1920s, Hitler and the Nazi Party introduced a 25-point doctrine. Our current government meets sixteen of these twenty-five points. While Fascism is a greater match (Trump arguably checks of all fourteen of Umberto Eco’s 14 points of Fascism identified in his essay “Ur-Fascism”), the similarities in the cultural philosophies of Fascism and Nazism make the distinction academic in most regards.

It is already happening here.

Consider the Trump administration’s attack on the Affordable Care Act. As scored by the CBO, 14 million Americans would lose health insurance.  Many of those would be the chronically ill and disabled, who would lose their current protections from provisions which block or dramatically reduce their benefits due to “pre-existing conditions.”

Then there is the GOP budget, which passed the House just this week. It cuts $1,000,000,000,000 (that’s one trillion dollars) from Medicaid spending. Medicaid not only protects the poor, it provides critical insurance coverage for the chronically ill and disabled which private insurance does not, like nursing services, durable medical equipment, skilled nursing facilities, long-term care, and more. These are life-saving services, and they are going to be eliminated for millions of people.

All of this takes place in the light of Trump’s own behavior (and those of his appointees) toward the disabled. Who can forget his mocking of a disabled reporter who interviewed him on the campaign trail?  Attorney General Jeff Sessions stated that services for disabled students were “accelerating the decline in civility and discipline in classrooms all over America” when a United States Senator. And just this week, Education Secretary Betsy DeVos rescinded 72 guidelines which clarified and specified protections for disabled students.

Into this context entered Rosa Maria Hernandez. A child with Cerebral Palsy. Also an undocumented immigrant, who was brought here when she was three months old because there was not sufficient medical care in her country. As she was being transferred in an ambulance between hospitals, Customs and Border Patrol agents performed an immigration check.  That’s correct, our government is so xenophobic,  it stops ambulances en route to the hospital to make sure they contain only legal residents. Here, they found this innocent ten-year-old girl who needed emergency surgery. They escorted her to the hospital, where they waited outside her room. The next day, when she was allowed to be discharged, she was detained, removed from her family to a facility 120 miles away to await deportation proceedings.

Our government has declared her a Useless Eater.  A nutzlose Esser.  Life unworthy of life.

Just like the Nazis would have.

And we have the opportunity, right now, to do what the German people did not do when Hitler started attacking the disabled. We have the opportunity, right now, to stop him. We have the obligation to stop him. To demand that tax cuts for billionaires are less important than medical care for the disabled. For children. For life with tremendous worth.

We have the ability and obligation to disobey. To disrupt. To demand that we live up to the basic tenets of humanity.

Or maybe he’ll come for your child next.

Contributing Editor: Ben Jackson

Ben Jackson is a writer and father of a chronically ill teenager who somehow still likes him. His non-fiction and opinion pieces have appeared in Patch Media, WBUR's Cognoscenti, and the Penmen Review. His fiction and poetry has been published in New Millennium Writings, The Legendary, 50 Word Stories, and anywhere else he can con an editor into buying his work. He lives in Natick, Massachusetts with his daughter.

5 Comments

  • Rosco1776
    Posted October 30, 2017 1:53 pm 0Likes

    Unlike the left who wants to kill them before they are born, wake up to the dividers and quit being divided!

  • Done with PCBS
    Posted October 30, 2017 8:17 pm 0Likes

    A guy we’ve known for 20 years gets disability for “issues with anxiety”so gets everything paid for. He got over $300k from his mom’s estate due to her settlement with breast implant settlement, plus her home & car which are paid for. He literally has no bills because welfare gives him food stamps, utility assistance, Medicaid, SSDI (the disability for people who’ve never worked since he worked for cash), and assistance for his **7** kids.

    We’ve turned him into the disability a n d welfare offices as fraud but they do not cancel him. He laughs and tells us about them investigating him but says he put everything into a trust in his mom’s name so they can’t touch him since it’s technically not his. He uses his mom’s trust debit card to buy what he wants, like a new Nissan Titan pickup, then claims her estate owns it. She’s been dead 15 yeas so why would it need a truck for him to drive?! So who really deserves the help here?!?

  • Fedup
    Posted October 30, 2017 8:38 pm 0Likes

    Why would they come for our kids next? Our parents and grand parents are legal immigrants, we were born here just like our kids. Why the fear mongering?Why are you so in love with illegal immigration? Don’t you realize countries that ignore laws don’t develop like countries that enforce the rule of law? You’re so desperate to have illegal immigrants here, you don’t want them to speak English, you don’t want them to use family planning. You just want enough Hispanics so the GOP will never win again.

  • corner
    Posted November 5, 2017 11:38 am 0Likes

    Hi, I ԁo think this iѕ an excellent website. I stumbledupon it 😉 I’m ɡoing to return once again since
    I bookmarked it. Ⅿoney and freedom is the best way
    to change, may you be rich and continue to guide others.

  • Jack
    Posted November 8, 2017 8:34 pm 0Likes

    Freeⅼancing can even lead too a giant “plus” regarding your income.
    Insteаd of hɑaving to accept the specific salɑry that is
    supplied byy the one regulatiοn firm that yоu simply work, you might have a
    substantial amount of ⅼeeway in setting your personal pay rates.

    This factor can lead to considerably extra money for you.

Add Comment