I am a Transgender Veteran and I have Something to Say

Last week’s tweets from President Trump stating that transgender people will not be allowed to join the military, and those currently serving will be administratively separated, shocked me. As a transgender veteran currently working in advocacy for transgender service members, I have spent the past five years of my life lobbying to ensure they can serve while bringing their full selves to the mission.

In that time, I have come to know our transgender troops. I’ve seen what they contribute to our national defense and how much they have endured to do so. Their determination and dedication are beyond question.

I don’t want anyone to have to make the choice between the career they love and who they are. I reached a point in my service in the '90s where I had to make that decision. I knew I couldn't come out to anyone without being administratively separated, much less transition. I suppressed my identity for another fifteen years, but in the end, it was too much. I left the reserves in order to transition.

I never stopped wanting to finish my career with honor and dignity. It had been my intention to rejoin the reserves this fall after the accessions policy was in place.
There is no valid reason for Trump’s policy. Transgender people are twice as likely to serve in the military as the general population. We’ve served honorably for decades and openly since 2015, when Secretary of Defense Ash Carter declared that while a new policy was being developed, military personnel would no longer be separated(i.e. discharged) for being transgender.

Trump's tweets seemed to shock Congress and the Pentagon as much as me. The policy allowing people to transition while serving was modeled after countries that have allowed this for decades and has gone relatively smoothly. Secretary of Defense James Mattis was asked about this issue during his confirmation hearings and consistently expressed support for retaining the current policy.

Even Senator John McCain, the Chairman of the Senate Armed Services Committee, who opposed the repeal of “Don’t Ask, Don’t Tell,” is opposed to banning transgender service members. In his office’s press release, he states, “The Department of Defense has already decided to allow currently-serving transgender individuals to stay in the military, and many are serving honorably today. Any American who meets current medical and readiness standards should be allowed to continue serving. “

The rationale of cutting costs makes no sense either. The issue of transgender service was studied at the behest of the Office of the Secretary of Defense, which concluded that the medical costs for transitioning service members would be “negligible.”Trump did not provide a source for those so-called "tremendous medical costs," but his administration has close ties to anti-LGBT groups that have actively advocated against allowing transgender people to serve in the military.

In my case, the cost argument makes even less sense. I paid for all of my transition-related expenses out of pocket after I went into the inactive reserves. My return to active duty would cost the military nothing in terms of medical care. Excluding me, however, costs the DoD the opportunity to benefit from my experience, knowledge, and skills.

That report commissioned by the Secretary of Defense also declares that the research on transgender inclusion in foreign militaries, though limited, "indicates little or no impact on unit cohesion, operational effectiveness, or readiness." There is no evidence that the current policy for U.S. troops has been any different.

However, what does impact mission readiness is losing good, dedicated people with no warning. Service members are often specialists with skills that are difficult to replace. Often a unit’s depth in these areas only goes “one deep.” A squadron that loses its lead maintenance check pilot, or a detachment that suddenly loses their only avionics technician, will suffer in terms of mission capability.

Worst, though, is the human toll this policy will take. If it goes through, I will never be in uniform again. I will lose 17 years of good service. Others have even more at stake. They stand to lose the careers they fought so hard for and the ability to support their families. They’re scared of what will happen to their units, their spouses, and children as a result of this outburst on social media.

These are good people, dedicated to serving their country, families, and units. All I want is to go back to the reserves so I can use my skills and talents to support U.S. national interests. Policy decisions with such profound effects on people lives should not be made on a whim via Twitter.

Brynn Tannehill.jpg

Contributing Editor: Brynn Tannehill

Brynn Tannehill, former Navy Lt. Cdr. and Director of Advocacy at SPARTA. Photo Via Getty Images

The White House

61 Comments

  • Michael Gagne
    Posted August 5, 2017 8:56 am 0Likes

    16 year CG active here. You have my support.

  • Tony Scruggs
    Posted August 5, 2017 5:18 pm 1Likes

    As the proud son of an LGBT father who was born on March Air Force Base, I feel GRATEFUL for your voice, for your empathic-honesty & for your contribution to our country.

    As an American of African-Ancestry raised w/the optimism of the American dream & the post civil-rights confidence of a butterfly having no memory of the chrysalis, my heart sank when I saw that tweet. IMHO not only was an entire group of team-humanity dismissed & stripped of their dignity, but all the allies & other groups teetering to be seen (w)hol(l)y experienced a spiritual gut punch as well.

    The GREAT news is that as a Power Empathy coach & former MLB’r (who was mentored by Gandhi’s grandson & Coach Wooden), I’ve seen competitive greatness & compassionate resistance. I’ve seen empathic transformation & nonviolent expansion. So whaddya say we empathize w/those in pain, connect at the heart level, roll up our sleeves & as my softball teammate Tony Danza likes to say ‘be the change we wish to see in the world’?

  • Barry Kaplan
    Posted August 7, 2017 3:18 pm 0Likes

    Your response will likely be to falsely call me a bigot, but I have zero issue with transgenders in civilian society. But YOU KNOW that the US military isn’t civilian society.

    The transgender community has a 40+% rate of attempted suicides in even the best circumstances. YOU KNOW this doesn’t align with military readiness. YOU KNOW that the military doesn’t accept people with chronic health conditions, to avoid facing situations where medical care isn’t available. “Transitioned” transgenders require ongoing care to simply maintain their appearance in uniform.

    NO ONE has a right to be in the US military. There’s a long list of mental, physical and educational scenarios that preclude people from joining OR serving. You’re asking for something that isn’t afforded to others, for the military to give you special treatment. Sorry, but you’re no better than any others who are turned away.

    This was originally much longer, but this site doesn’t allow more thought out responses.

  • Pingback: fruit
  • Pingback: friv
  • Pingback: agen bola
  • Pingback: Corporate Event Managers for Companies in Hyderabad
  • charter
    Posted November 16, 2017 1:07 am 0Likes

    It’s really a cool and useful piece of info.
    I’m glaԁ that you shaгed thiѕ uѕeful info with us.

    Please keep us informed like this. Thank you for sharing.

  • Pingback: DMPK Contract Research Organization
  • Pingback: make money with a iphone
  • Pingback: Best Engineer Aws Alkhazraji coehuman
  • Pingback: Political 1Diyala
  • Pingback: cpns kabupaten rembang 2018
  • Pingback: corporate event management companies
  • Pingback: iraqilaws
  • Pingback: GVK BIO New Deals
  • Pingback: pk studies in drug discovery
  • Pingback: warehouses for rent
  • Pingback: blog link
  • Pingback: womensuits
  • Pingback: cmovieshd
  • Pingback: SEO consultants
  • Pingback: Digital Brand Recognition
  • Judi
    Posted May 11, 2018 3:16 pm 0Likes
  • Adu ayam
    Posted May 14, 2018 8:11 pm 0Likes

    This is article is very nice, amazing anda good.
    You have given me an idea for my blog. I am very grateful to you.
    S128

  • dompetcasino
    Posted May 28, 2018 8:11 am 0Likes

    DOMPETCASINO ONLINE JUDI CASINO ONLINE ONLINE AND CHICKEN SABUNG

    Online gambling sites nowadays have become a very many things encountered in the internet world. One of the most popular online gambling games today is online poker and online casinos. Therefore now present gambling sites and dominoqq online poker named Dompetcasino. We are now here to help meet online gambling demands. Dompetcasino itself also provides 7 types of games that you can play enough with 1 User ID only. The games are cockfighting, baccarat, sicbo, rulette, dragon tiger, game slots and online casinos. The game that we provide of course quite complete dong ya.

  • dompetpoker
    Posted May 28, 2018 8:12 am 0Likes

    best online money poker agent with the best server only on the dompetpoker
    tbk dompetpoker is site / website agency gambling poker online money with the best service and supported by friendly service services.

  • Pingback: trenbolone
  • Pingback: diyala+ sciences
  • Pingback: Predrag Timotić
  • Pingback: Webcam chat
  • Pingback: Denture Repair
  • Pingback: cum compilation
  • Pingback: bitcoin betting
  • Agen Bola
    Posted July 15, 2018 1:17 pm 0Likes

    nice article

  • Meisyaga
    Posted July 15, 2018 1:20 pm 0Likes

    thank you, your info is very interesting. hopefully this info from you can be useful for all people in the world. Agen Taruhan Terpercaya

  • Pingback: 토토사이트
  • Pingback: can vs slovakia
  • Pingback: Huawei phone
  • Pingback: buy cc fullz
  • Pingback: instakram orospulari
  • Pingback: pharmacokinetic study
  • poker online
    Posted August 15, 2018 3:06 pm 0Likes

    Dompetpoker.org is a card game that shares betting rules and is usually (but not always) in hand ranking. The Poker Online game is different in terms of how cards are shared. In the most modern Poker Games, the first round of betting starts with several forms. Type of card arrangement in Online Poker.

    poker online

  • liveskor
    Posted August 15, 2018 3:07 pm 0Likes

    4KGOAL.com 4kgoal’s live score Indonesia website provides live scores soccer, matches from all leagues and daily game schedules

    is a soccer information site, Livescore, Soccer Schedule, Interactive Soccer Scores and as a community for bookies and bettors to get information.

    With a good background in the football industry, 4KGOAL.com has an outstanding editorial team. Sports information and data is displayed in full including several types of sports such as football, basketball, tennis, badminton and so forth.

    liveskor

  • judi online
    Posted August 15, 2018 3:07 pm 0Likes

    The best online gambling agent is Bandar Slot, Casino SBOBET 338a, maxbet, mr8asia, Betting Prediction, Biggest and Most Trusted in Indonesia. Free Signup Process! You can directly play with less than 3 minutes process.
    Judi Online is an agile basketball player, Casino SBOBET 338a, ibcbet, Betting Prediction and slot game, Biggest and Most Trusted in Indonesia
    judi online

  • poker online
    Posted August 15, 2018 3:08 pm 0Likes

    Welcome to AsetQQ.com, the Best and Most Trusted Indonesian Online Poker Site. AsQQQ provides 6 games that can be played in 1 User Id only. Online Poker, DominoQQ, Bandar Ceme, Capsa Susun, Live Poker, Ceme Keliling Games, using Indonesian real money
    poker online

  • agen bola
    Posted August 15, 2018 3:08 pm 0Likes

    Best and Reliable Best Online Casino and Casino Agent in Indonesia. Bandarbola88 GIVING THE WARRANTY OF OUR CUSTOMER SATISFACTION WITH SUPPORTED BY OUR RELIABLE TEAM CUSTOMER SERVICE AND EXPERIENCED. WE GUARANTEE YOUR SECURITY AND COMFORT JOIN WITH US. OUR CUSTOMER SERVICE STAFF WILL BE READY TO BE CONTACTED 24/7 THROUGH VARIOUS COMMUNICATIONS METHOD WE HAVE PROVIDED. WE WILL PROCESS ALL ONLINE TRANSACTIONS OR E-BANKINGS IN TIME LESS THAN 3 MINUTES. Bandarbola88 Gambling Agent Online Casino, WINING WILL BE WILL PAY, JOIN TOGETHER WITH US !!!!!!

    agen bola

  • poker online
    Posted August 15, 2018 3:09 pm 0Likes

    go88poker.com is a trusted online poker site for gambling games Poker, Domino, Bandar Ceme, Bandar Capsa. No matter how much you win, we definitely pay. The go88poker.com site is guaranteed to be safe and reliable. 100% player vs player without robot.
    poker online

  • Pingback: newtube sirius216 abdu23na3212 abdu23na86
  • Pingback: new siriustube582 abdu23na7416 abdu23na70
  • Pingback: naked children
  • Pingback: sfgjidfgn166 afeu23na955 abdu23na28
  • Pingback: sfgjidfgn615 afeu23na8238 abdu23na50
  • Pingback: putas madrid
  • Pingback: sfgjidfgn670 afeu23na2575 abdu23na81
  • judi casino indonesia
    Posted September 12, 2018 12:19 pm 0Likes

    When I initially commented Ι seеm to have clicked the -Notify mе when new comments ɑгe aⅾded- checkbox аnd from noѡ
    on whenever a comment iss added I receive four emails with thе exact sаme
    comment. Ιs there аn easy method youu can remove mе
    from that service? Tһank you!

  • judi casino indonesia
    Posted September 14, 2018 8:11 am 0Likes

    Ӏ ɗo not even ҝnow h᧐ѡ I ended սp here, but I thougһt thіs post was good.
    I do not know who yоu are but defіnitely you ɑre going
    to a famous blogger іf you are not aⅼready 😉 Cheers!

  • Hack Bandar Sakong
    Posted September 21, 2018 8:14 pm 0Likes

    I think your site is very good and provides high-class value, then it works on this site and I’m sure this will help many people

  • Hack Bandar
    Posted September 21, 2018 8:16 pm 0Likes

    I have an opinion that suits you, and I am sure your site is very much waiting for many people to come forward today for this kind of work
    http://www.hackpokerv.com/

  • Pingback: Branding
  • Pingback: 2019

Add Comment